A “master copy” is a study of artwork originally done by a “master artist”, to try to understand that artist’s techniques and practice observational skills. As expected, a lot of museums have residencies or programming to encourage master copying. But day-to day, a masterful piece of artwork can be that art you saw online, or in my case as a kid, the covers of the shojo manga “Kitchen Princess”. Wanting to make master copies is natural because we want to understand how to make that picture we like. The reasons for master copying are vast: to see if you could do it, to learn how hard it is, to get a closeness to the master artist, to have a pretty picture done in your hand to hang on the wall, etc.

But after a decade of doing hyperrealistic art where I essentially copied from original photos, the idea of doing a master copy bored me to tears. I did occasionally feel a surge of optimism to challenge that in the name of learning techniques. But I kept confirming my hypothesis over and over again

this was my attempt at my own version of a Sargent, and I STILL got bored

.

A few weeks ago, my friend S was looking to commission an artist to create a master copy of this painting that is widespread on social media:

there are many different crops of the same painting, but I found this one revealed the most

We couldn’t find the artist anywhere, even with our top-notch online sleuthing abilities (there is evidence to support that we are very good at this, I promise!). So with no prints to buy, or original artist to credit, we were a bit at a loss…but ethically, we thought it would be okay to consider this an opportunity for an artist to do a master copy. Hesitantly, at the end of our call, I offered to try it myself as an “aRtiSt”. We both knew I was healing my relationship to art, so I’d check in often about how valuable versus stressful the experience felt. The deadline would be our day spent in Manhattan (we hadn’t seen each other in TWO years!).

First, I did a brown wash, lightly sketched, and blocked in the blue of the water.

my first sketch attempt

We tried a landscape, too.

the sketch got a bit lazier, but I was focused on the hands being the center of the painting!

A few days passed. The landscape seemed promising at this point. I put down a more defined sketch, which has not been my usual method. My recent paintings have felt more intuitive and abstract, but that is probably definitely not the point with a master copy.

the burnt umber lines mean serious business; also note that there’s no plant under the left arm, at S’s request!

More color blocking. The fingers in the original looked odd to me, but I decided not to fix them very much. I also don’t understand finger anatomy very well, anyway.

was seeing a bit more of the vision at this point…

It was only on the second to last day before our outing, that I realized I had not captured the feeling of the original painting at ALL. I spent so much time on these dang hands, the physical elements, that I had lost focus of the mix of the muddy and vibrant colors, and the soft edges.

My perfectionism was really challenged at this point: I had promised S that the painting was contingent on me having a good time, but my fear was roaring. She wouldn’t want this painting…the feeling, the atmosphere were the most important parts of the original! I HAVE FAILED I AM A FAILURE NO ONE WOULD WANT THIS. But if I tried to nuke some major parts of this painting this late, would I be able to finish? If I offered to send this to her at a later date, could I ever bring myself to ship it, because it would always feel so imperfect? Would I be so disheartened by the process that I give up?

In the end, I accepted that this was the best I could do for now. The worst scenario, which would absolutely happen if I delayed the date, was that I’d grow scared of painting, and she would never receive it. If the expectation were a master copy, I didn’t fail, but fell somewhere in the middle between that and a complete success.

But at least it was evidence of how much I loved and cared for my friend. And evidence of my brush strokes during this late March/early April of 2025. There is value in that enough.

So on that last night, I poured some glossy varnish, and took this photo in my embarrassingly pink pajama set.

Thanks to S for the opportunity to make this recreation for you—it challenged my opinion of the value of my artwork, helped me find value in attempting a master copy, and a video essay talked to me about Pilot Pete’s Bachelor season.

now that this was written imperfectly…be gone!

(Written in 54 minutes)